Why Leadership Judgement is an SJT – and When It’s Worth It

Situational Judgement Tests (SJTs) are a familiar format in recruitment – but their role in leadership diagnostics is less widely understood. One reason: Leadership is messy, ambiguous, and hard to reduce to “right or wrong” answers. And yet, tools like the Ixly ACT Digit Series use the SJT format exactly for that. So what’s behind this method – and when does it make sense?

What exactly is an SJT?

A Situational Judgement Test presents short, real-world scenarios and asks candidates to evaluate or rank response options. Instead of measuring traits or intelligence directly, SJTs aim to assess applied judgement in a given context.

In the leadership context, this means: How does a person actually respond to complex, people-centered situations? Do they escalate, avoid, manipulate – or do they find a solution that balances outcomes, people, and long-term goals?

Why use it for leadership?

Leadership is not about textbook answers. It’s about navigating trade-offs, conflict, and uncertainty. That’s why classic SJTs often fall short – they’re too simple. But when tailored specifically for leadership situations and backed by a robust logic model (like in Ixly’s case), the SJT format becomes a sharp lens on behavioural preferences.

What this type of test reveals is not just what someone would do – but how they prioritise, how they interpret responsibility, and how they handle grey zones.

Need an SJT provider? Not every diagnostics company offers high-quality SJTs.

See the shortlist →

When is it worth using?

If you’re in a small or mid-sized company and you’re hiring (or promoting) someone into a key leadership position, you don’t need theory – you need a sense of how this person will actually lead. An SJT-based tool is helpful when:

• You want to move beyond “gut feeling”interviews
• You need fast, scalable diagnostics
• You care about leadership behaviour, not just personality

It’s also practical: Most SJT tools, including Ixly’s, are digital, time-efficient (about 10–15 minutes), and easy to interpret. That makes them attractive for lean HR setups with little time and no diagnostics department.

‼️What it doesn’t do

Let’s be clear: An SJT is not a deep psychological profile. It won’t tell you about inner risk patterns, clinical derailers, or unconscious biases. For that, you’d need more in-depth tools like Hogan or Aon modules.

But for behaviour-based leadership screening, SJTs hit the sweet spot between insight and efficiency – if, and only if, the tool is well-designed.